maharetr: Comic and movie images of Aisha's eyebrow ring (The Losers) (Default)
( Oct. 5th, 2024 08:39 pm)
Finished reading
A question of age : women, ageing[,] and the forever self by Jacinta Parson. Mum read this one as an audiobook as her before sleep read, and recced this to me, and I'm really interested to hear what she got out of it. Reading it as a print book was probably much less enjoyable.

As someone who just turned 40, I'm starting to get very interested in engaging with ageing and what it means in our culture, and figuring out what it means to me personally. I am extremely here for whatever the 'forever self' might be. I have no fucking idea what it is, actually, having now read this book.

I'm used to non-fiction books that are either collections of essays with discrete points, or books that are chapters building on previous arguments. This was a book that purported to be the latter, but read like the former, and I found it immensely frustrating as a result. It made some really good starting points in each chapter that then...went nowhere. Seriously, this table of contents (Amazon link to the sample) looks so structured and Going Somewhere and argh. Each handful of pages makes a really entrancing point, that goes fucking hard reset into the next point that will have nothing to do with the one that came before it, or the one that comes after it, and reaches zero conclusions. I expected each element to relate to a time of life, but each introduction resets to her childhood memory of that element and then bounces all over the place.

It feels like this is the first draft of something that needs to have its core points written on sticky notes and reordered into an actual whole, and god, I really really want to read that. I am so sad its not that, and I can't tell if it's my own expectations, or if I'm trying to impose a structure on something that doesn't need it, or what. Ugh.
maharetr: Comic and movie images of Aisha's eyebrow ring (The Losers) (Default)
( Sep. 22nd, 2024 05:22 pm)
Finished reading
The Adventures of Amina Al-Sirafi by S.A. Chakraborty. This was FUN. I loved the take on demons, and really liked Amina and her crew. The latter parts of the supernatural elements felt as interesting and as consequential as a dream sequence (which is to say, not very), but the author made the 'recounting story to a scribe" WORK, in beautiful, effective hindsight, and she gets many kudos for that. I'll gladly pick up book 2, doubly so if there's a 'the story so far' refresher at the front.

Big magic by Elizabeth Gilbert. Filled with woo and vibes about being creative, but they're *impeccably* my woo and vibes. Read a library copy, and then turned around and went out and bought my own copy.

Nimona by ND Stevenson. I saw the movie first (which I LOVED), and it's hard to tell if I'm unfairly judging the original text by the one that came second, or if it's actually wobbly as a book. It *really* feels to me like a 'started, gonna see where this goes, hey!' web comic. Which it was! And isn't automatically a bad thing (see: Digger by Ursula Vernon, which I think was also this but didn't feel like it), but it kinda... I feel like the movie was better, because as a text it *had* to make coherent sense from the get go, whereas a pantsed web comic doesn't.

The moon of crusted snow by Waubgeshig Rice. Been on my TBR pile forever, finally got it from the library. This was...sadly inconsistent for me. Someone in reviews suggested it should be read more as a fable than as a post-apoca story, and that shift in thinking did help, post-read. A First Nations (North American) community is cut off from the rest of the world by a power outage that also affects the rest of probably the country. I'm still very torn on it in multiple directions. general thoughts, positive and negative. No real spoilers ) I'd be really interested in others' thoughts, if you've read it.

The reluctant hallelujah by Gabrielle Williams. This was an impulse secondhand bookshop buy. Australian YA. I was taken in by the title and the cover, and by the strong, assured teenage Aussie voice that was effortlessly rolling along the page. Teen girl goes on road trip to convey Secret of her parents, who have gone missing.

I finished it in three hours of holiday afternoon, and I would absolutely actively seek out more by this author and...did not like this particular book, thinking back on it. It started with a solid premise: parents haven't come home, they have a Secret that their teen has to deal with, and transport. Excellent premise. Except spoilers ) The MacGuffin could have been anything and the author went with...that, and also didn't touch it, but also it was such a good Australian teen voice and I am so *clutches hair and growls in frustration*.

Currently reading:
Diving back into Witch king by Martha Wells, which I'd gotten 70-odd pages into during Hugo reading and realised I wanted to savour rather than rush through for a deadline. Picking it back up has been remarkably difficult on the executive function, but I'm back in at page 40 or so, and finding the swing again.

A question of age: women, ageing and the forever self by Jacinta Parsons. Recced by my mum who did it as an audiobook. I have a library paperback, and it's...hmm. Is there a word for purple prose that's a totally different colour but also same vibe? idek. I want to support the idea very, very much and I'll definitely give it 50 pages (possibly 100 pages given the ease of the page layout) but I'm cautious.

Up next:
It's taken me this long to get back into the reading swing, I don't really want to jinx things, but maybe The artist's way by Julia Cameron.
This is me walking in quietly and sitting in the corner. Much has happened, and is happening, but y'know. Books.

I've finished-read a few things, or read samples a bunch more. We did a bunch of reading a work and I've brought home almost the entire Discworld collection and have it under my bed. I'd read most of the Death books in high school, and many of the Witches books in young adulthood, so now it's time for the City Watch.

Guards, Guards! I think this was a re-read, but t's long enough ago that it barely counts. I was very charmed by this. Epic kudos for the first proper appearance of the dragon over the city -- I felt the weight of that take-off, and the physicality of that dragon, holy hell.

Men at arms which I've just started. I don't think I've read this one at all, which is exciting, but it also seems heavy on the 'white cis guy grappling with the first wave of affirmative action' and oh, boy. I'm not sure I want to read something where I'm likely to be bracing for what are now Very Tired Jokes, and missteps, and, and. Ugh. Is it better than I fear?

I've also sorted a pile of books that have been lurking invisibly in my room for a very long time. Sorted into 'definite keeps', 'op-shop run', and 'read the first fifty pages while on holidays'. I'm so fucking grateful for the holidays, oh my god.

Hi, everyone. It's good to be back. How you all doing?
Finished reading:
Or rather, am finished with the book.
Family of origins by CJ Hauser. So 18 months ago (such a goddamn long time ago), Hauser's article The crane wife went viral for profoundly deserved, emotionally-devastating reasons. Based on that article, I asked my library system to buy a copy of her book when it came out, a year ago (still So Fucking Long ago). It finally came in, juuuust in time for my Xmas break.

I picked it up based on the writing strength of the article. The quality of the book was...not as great. This feels like a novel that was started in a creative writing class. Some of those are incredibly good! This was a 'I'll try again with her second novel' She's deliberately not used speech marks, which...can work? But Tim Winton she's not, and it's been long enough since I read Cloudstreet that I'm not even sure it totally worked for Winton, either. It's very...there are the occassional flashes of emotional brilliance (what I suspect she was able to distil her article down into), and that kept me going through a lot of the rest of the overwrittenness. A couple of things kept me reading: one of the characters put in an application to go to Mars as a civilian settler, and makes the interview shortlist, which to me put it far enough in the future that I was genuinely interested in all the other ways Hauser thought the near-future was going to be. Also, I would 100% believe that Hauser has a secret or not-so-secret AO3 account and a love for the spoiler ) fandom. I'm not into said fandom per se, but I'm curious about the workings of said, and both of those things got me to about the half way mark.

Then at the halfway mark, I started to suspect that the trip to Mars was more an exploration of the character's feelings, rather than a 10-20 years into the future jump. I started to realise I didn't actually like either of these characters much, either. I calculated approximately how long it was going to take me to read the other half, decided I'd rather spend those hours doing something else, and jumped forward to read the final chapter. I don't regret any of it. I'd interestedly pick up her second novel from the library. The crane wife is still an incredible article.

Currently reading:
The invisible life of Addie LaRue by V.E. Schwab
A young woman in 1700s France unthinkingly stumbles into a monkey's paw deal with a night god. "I don't want to be forced into a marriage/I don't want to belong to anyone/I want to live a full life and then you can have my soul when I don't want it anymore" becomes a cursed immortality of "everyone will forget you".

This is...also overwritten, but in a way that I'm willing to read past because the underlying themes--being forgotten by everyone, being unable to leave any intentional mark of your own--hits me in the heart so hard. I don't love Addie per se, yet, but I love, love relationship loops, and trying to leave whatever mark however indirectly, and trying to have a meaningful life. I love the woman Addie fell in love with, Sam; and I love, love Henry, the man who, Addie's just realised, can remember who she is. Considering she stole a book from his shop yesterday, this is a problem...

Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke. Eternally on the current list, I'm sure. It's gotten overlooked with all the new shinies from the library and Xmas, so I'm mostly listing it here to keep it in the mental pile.

Up next:
SO MANY GOOD Christmas presents.
The faceless old woman who lives in your home -- a Welcome to Nightvale novel with a killer of an opening line. Idk if it's going to be able to sustain an entire novel's worth of this tight brilliance, and if it can, if it's going to be too exhausting to read, but I'm excited to find out.

The dictionary of lost words by Pip Williams. A fictional take on women's perspectives during the creation of the Oxford dictionary. Loved the sample.

The once and future witches by Alix E. Harrow. Purely on my adoration of The ten thousand doors of January
maharetr: Comic and movie images of Aisha's eyebrow ring (The Losers) (Default)
( Jul. 6th, 2020 02:53 pm)
aaahhh Finally getting back in the saddle, so to speak. Not putting–or trying not to put—pressure on myself to post these regularly, just when I have the cope, I wrote, some months ago. And then the whole pandemic, obviously, and things went even more pear-shaped. I'm letting the Hugos slide by this year, and making peace with that. I don't think the cost of the individual things I might want to read equals the cost of a supporting membership, either.

Finished reading:
  • The thousand doors of January by Alix E. Harrow. January is a biracial girl in early 1900s England and Europe, who discovers she can write her desires into existence. I loved this. It was luscious and almost overwritten and I ate every word. It ends somewhat rushed, but I also loved one of the closing paragraphs so much that I took a photo of it before I returned it to the library. It’s on my Hugo nomination ballot, even, such as that is. (Months later update: Yay! It made it! I'm super interested in its nomination numbers post-Hugos now, too.)
  • The last unicorn by Peter S. Beagle. Has been on my vague wanna list for forever. I’m surprised at how dark it is so far, honestly, but thoroughly, if slowly, enjoying it. The writing is so skilled and occasionally catch-my-breath amazing. I’d expected to adore Molly Grue based on this gifset, and I came to like her, but it was Smendrick – his bumbling, low-level ineptness as he just tries to keep his head down and stay out of trouble – that was the unexpected star for me. It's such a dark tale, with the carnival – the harpy was genuinely unsettling – and the cursed Hagsville. It's impressively dark, actually. It's also taking me triple the amount of time I thought it would take to read it. I'm butting up against a renewal notice from the library, and that's on a three week loan. Later update: Slogged through to the end, but/and the final pages made it immensely worth it. The last five pages, settled deep in self-aware wryness, were an actual pleasure. I'm glad I read the book, overall.)
  • The goblin emperor by Katherine Addison. (Review from over many, many weeks' reading) I've heard many people adore this one, and I'm interested to give it a proper go. Oh my heart. Maia is the exiled son of the emperor's discarded fourth wife, which makes him approx. 5th in line for the throne and never ever intended to rule. One airship accident later… 
This is one of those books where I don't understand the intricacies of the plot, and I'm only barely hanging onto who is who, but the heart and soul of the novel, and its main characters, are wonderful. Even the glossary of names and places isn't useful, because many of the names are listed Lastname, Firstname, and the characters are generally only referred to regularly as firstname. So many multi-syllable names, (no apostrophes, tho!). And yet, and yet, I'm appreciating every breath of kindness and empathy and connection so much that I don't care. I'm deeply here for rituals and etiquette and being able to see the flashes of humanity and connection and people under all of those layers, and there is so much of it. ("We thank you for that which the Serenity does not do." I SOB.)

I remember seeing several people saying this was their every-few-years re-read, and 130ish pages in, I believe them utterly. I've renewed this inter-library loan, and I'm still not sure I'll finish it in time, but I'm also planning on buying my own copy so I can do the every-few-years re-read.

UPDATE: I have in fact purchased myself a copy. I'm very pleased to see the paperback version has the pronunciation guide and the names guide in the front of the book, and listed in the contents page.

At page 250, I started to lightly wonder where the queers were, triply so considering I can't at first glance tell gender from any of the names. Then I read this in Addison's Goodreads profile (not spoilery, because I'm almost certain it's referencing a character that we get no more than a passing reference to, but under a cut just in case
Read more... )

And I just about fall to the floor in incoherent worship. I would pay SO MUCH MONIES to read that.

So I'd wondered, and then I read the above, and then I went out and bought my own paperback, and then finally I read my way to the queer, and I … hesitate some. I don't regret buying it, and I'm very, very still reading, in that slow way of mine with a dense second world like this. But so far at page 270ish, it's enough to give it a "Goodreads 5 stars, actual rating 4.5". I don't want to spoil in this post itself, and it might all work out great in text, so I'm reserving judgement, hopefully. Feel very free to ask for more detail in comments. Many months' later update: I can only hazily remember the specific details, but I'm happy to dredge them up. Having finished it, the queer rep issue wasn't resolved satisfactorily in-text, but having said that, the alleged sequel (announced 2018, no further details) seems to be fully about said in-text-queer person, so my candle flame of hope is unwavering.
  • A lady's guide to petticoats and piracy by MacKenzi Lee. I really enjoyed her first one, A gentleman's guide to vice and virtue, and this one was…close, but was more of an unrealized potential. There were excellent moments early on: Felicity hanging out with Monty and Percy was an utter, warm, loving joy that I shall cradle to my heart for a long, long time. I want to create that feeling in other people with my writing, even. But many of the other characters – Joanna and Sim, for example, had such nearly-fully-realized potential that I ached at that gap. Also the plot … wasn't. I kept waiting for it to start, honestly, rather than having the characters meander around, and it never quite happened. So I'm delighted to have it on my shelf to read those first few chapters over and over, but the book as a whole didn't quite make it for me. Useful learning reading!

Finally finishing The Goblin Emperor and working my way through Petticoats and piracy marked the start of my pandemic reading. Then I was delighted to stumble across this list https://bookriot.com/feel-good-fantasy-books/. I sampled my way through this list and decided to order about 6 of them.

Didn't finish:
  • Witchmark by C L Polk. I wanted to like this so much! And it was close, so close to being good. But while the book laid out an interesting magic/electricity world, and a nice romance, at 130ish/320 pages, I didn't care about the central plot-point murder, and the goodreads reviews I tentatively read said that the book does that debut novel thing of never quite getting deep enough into its themes (trauma healing, magical healing, PTSD, enslavement etc). After slogging through the previous book of not-quite-working, I'm being Strong, Dammit, and putting it aside.

Currently reading:
  • A green and ancient light by Frederic S. Durbin. This sample snagged me hard emotionally within the first few sample pages (adults sincerely respecting kids' personhood and internal lives are my absolute weakness), and now re-reading it with the physical book, it's doing it just effectively. I keep hesitating at certain points of reveal, worried that it won't keep being as good, and at about a third of the way through, it's still standing up, I say in part to coax myself to keep reading. The blurb quote bills it as "Mythic in its universality" which it is in fact decidedly not -- it feels very clearly WW2 evacuated-to-British countryside, even if it's very careful not to name itself (or any of the main characters, which feels delightful in a whole other charming way), but I'm still very much loving it.
  • The mysterious Benedict Society by Trenton Lee Stewart. More distinctly a children's book than I usually read, but fucking delightful and cosy at 30 pages in.


A to-sample-reads list, as haphazard as it might be:
Ash, by Malinda Lo
The girls of paper and fire, by Natasha Ngan
Tags:
Finished reading:
Nothing totally finished this cycle, technically. BUT

Currently reading:
Exhalation by Ted Chiang, which half way through has been a rollercoaster of up and down reading.

The merchant and the alchemist's gate. The story that I thought was going to be the hardest to get into turned out to be my overwhelmed-by-feels standout. It's a nested stories-within-a-story, and all of them deftly play to my love of time travel and healing and pieces clicking into place just so. Deeply satisfying.

Exhalation A strange, detailed look at mechanical people investigating themselves in much the same way we try to, but with the advantages of being able to take themselves apart. I'm not entirely sure of the point, per se. I picked up allusions to climate change and the like, I just wasn’t sure what to do with them.

What's expected of us A small unsettling story that I think I read before it was published here. What would you do if it were proved that we had no free will?

The lifecycle of software objects Digients (essentially very advanced tamagotchis) are raised in virtual worlds. I wanted to love this story. Reading the author notes afterwards, I really wanted to love the story he said he was inspired to write, but the story he actually wrote was…hmm. He chose to write it in a very distanced, telling-not-showing style, which was jarring. And then the digients spoke like toddlers, even after years and years of literal schooling, and it was abrading my nerves long before the topic of essentially selling them for sex work was raised, at which point it started grating through my nerves into rage. This was…possibly the goal? But I feel like either he or I missed the point, if it was.

Dacey's patent automatic nanny A beautifully-voiced museum interpretation of an automated nanny: the horrible, 'rational' misogynistic man who thought up such a device, and the adult son who used it on the grandchild, and it was all deeply unsettling and very well done.

Up next:
The rest of Exhalation.

The girl who drank the moon by Kelly Barnhill which is on hold for me at the library.

Because internet which I've not bought yet, despite my excitement.
Finished reading:
The Testaments by Margaret Atwood.
Huh. Where to start? I know that some of my reactions to various things were blunted because I'd already processed the things having read surprisingly … not spoilery, but a surprisingly detailed descriptions of some book moments in a review. So, I'll go below a cut.

No explicit spoilers I don't think, but don't read if you'd rather go in cold to your own read )

We who are about to… by Joanna Russ, published 1976.
A spaceship accident strands a small, disparate group of people on an unknown planet, hundreds of years from rescue. The female narrator isn’t interested in uselessly maintaining humanity. The first half of this was more harrowing reading than The Testaments, actually. For all that Gilead is horrific, and chews people up and spits them out, there’s a structure here, even if it sucks. Like the Joker says: “Everyone stays calm if things are going to plan. Even if the plan’s horrifying.”

Is there a point to surviving? Is there a point to keeping ‘humanity’ going in a place where natural attrition means we’ll die out much sooner rather than later? Russ says no, and while I’m hypothetically inclined to agree, watching the disagreements flare into violence and force and then disintegrate entirely, is grim stuff. I was utterly gripped by the first half. The second half meandered as the character chose to starve, and then gripped me for the last few pages so tightly I barely breathed.

There’s an opacity to Russ’s writing – there’s conclusions reached or ideas formed that seem to be happening just under the surface of the paragraphs, and I can’t tell if that’s the narrative choice to not state them aloud, or if I’m not making the connections. I’m also not sure if it’s a 1970s thing or a Russ thing. I’m pretty sure I found similar issues with the parts of The female man that I read. Glad I read it, if only to have read something from 45ish years ago. Not sure how I felt about it as a novella unto itself.


Currently reading:

The second mountain by David Brooks
Absolutely captivated by his chapters on the valley and the wilderness – those metaphorical (or literal) times when life smacks you off your stable perch and leaves you rattled and questioning everything, and you need to go away for a while to reassess you Everything. Less convinced by his writing on the soul – I think we have one, but I also think animals have souls, too. I am deeply distrustful of any ‘things that separate us from animals!’ spiels at this point. Although I think he’s talking about a moral centre and I’m talking about a life force, so *shrug*. Continuing to read with interest, little bits at a time.

To be taught, if fortunate by Becky Chambers.
Started! I love her concepts SO MUCH. I keep forgetting her writing isn’t as quite as polished and deft in turn. This is still good, twenty ish pages in.


Up next:
Argh, I feel like there’s so many, again, but my brain’s not working.
Finished reading
On eating meat by Matthew Evans. I stalled out on this one for a while there, and I’m not totally sure why. Possibly because I was feeling bogged down in a technical details and the like, and when I don’t have a whole lot of brain to spare, it all felt like too much effort. Have pulled through that and into the later part of the book which is about balancing humanity’s diets and land use. It’s really noticeably western-centric in these parts. Not in an unexpected way, I guess, but there’s been no mention of the entire swaths of the world that are lactose-intolerant (or, to put it more realistically, have not needed to develop the tolerances to consume another species’ milk). And possibly he doesn’t need to mention it, it just feels like a notable silence.

Having now finished. He makes some excellent points (by which I mean I agree with a lot of them, if not all of them), but it also feels a bit like all he's made are points, rather than a coherent overarching argument. Part of that might be that there are just a lot of disparate points that make up a whole, but it also made for disjointed reading, which was also possibly why it took me so long. Chapters didn't flow into each other or connect to each other, and even the points made within chapters didn't flow, and were often broken up with a … I don't know the technical term, a fancy page break symbol, which didn't help. 3.5 whatevers out of 5.

Currently reading
How powerful we are by Sally Rugg. All of the behind-the-scenes (and before camera) activism by GetUp and co on the campaign for marriage equality. Sally Rugg is fantastic, and I'm loving this, and have been inhaling this. The wins and the sacrifices, the regrets, and the raging, and the battle still to come.

The second mountain by David Brooks. Tentative chapter skimming. Reading the introduction, and already found an 'oof' line: "A commitment is falling in love with something and then building a structure of behaviour around it for those moments when love falters." (page xx)


Up next

I have a Plan, Goddammit. Once I finish Powerful, I get to buy The Testaments on Tuesday from Rabble Books. Oh god so much trepidation, so much interest. There’s talk of it being about the downfall of the Gilead regime, and I trust Atwood to do it much, much more than I trust the show to show a rebellion/fighting back against Gilead.

I'm also gonna read the 13th doctor's short story, which I got from the library, purely because Naomi Alderman wrote a 13 story, and I’m here for both of these things, so hard. And then work my way backwards through the doctors, and see how many I get through.

Longer-term side plans.

Becky Chambers novella "To be taught, if fortunate..", and the Joanna Russ novella "Those who are about to…". I learned about the latter after reading about the former, and they sound like the flip sides of the same coin – both extensive space travel, one brutally grim and the other hopeful. We'll see.

The post-apoca book of fun by Rachel Sharp.

I also somewhere in all this want to watch the last season of Black sails. Oh, self.
As I emerge, blinking, from the depths of months of Hugo reading…

Finished reading:

Vox Machina : Origins (I, graphic novel)
I'd heard...not great things? But they were going Cheap, and I'd been hearing Much better things about Origins II that's just rolling off the press now, so.
Vox Machina : Origins I, Issue 1 wow, so Matt Colville really doesn't like Vex, huh? (I don't know the difference between a 'story by' and a 'script' credit, but I'm stubbornly in denial that Matt Mercer might have written Vex that cold) Having said that, the twins banter actually still made me laugh aloud, and the comedic timing with Keyleth was pitch-perfect. So that's rather large something. And I like the art a lot.
Issue 2...it's sort of a problem when I legit feel more for the random nameless paladins and their dead party member, and like Tiberius Stormlord, more than Grog or Scanlan. Like, that's not great. Then on into Issues 3-6 The comedic timing of the twins becomes actual sniping and arguing when they're alone, apparently, and I hate that. The art is still impressive, but I'm feeling like this is a comic that's really only for diehard fans, and I say that as someone who's watched nearly the first quarter of campaign 1. Or it's just not that great. I have more hopes for Origins II, given that's being helmed by the woman who's also writing/helming the animated series. Also I've heard people who've griped about I speak far more warmly about II

The crane wife by CJ Hauser. Okay, it's not a book, but I still want to quietly cup it in my hands and offer it to people. It's a memoir article by a woman who cancelled her wedding a week out from the big day, and why, and how she's grappling with her life, and it's fucking devastatingly good. Content notes for infidelity, but also subtle, brutally effective gaslighting and emotional abuse. It made me cry, and made me feel infinitely fragile and also bigger than I had been before I started it. Set aside ten minutes to read it, and then time after for a quiet sit and a cup of tea, or something.

Currently reading:
Blackout: how is energy-rich Australia running out of energy? by Matthew Warren The 'setting of the basic groundwork' of the early chapters was also 'teetering in the edges of my ability to understand and retain'. A diagram or two might have helped. I'm deep in the chapter on political decisions that got us to now, and all the places that I'm seeing where things could have been achingly different. I didn't know Melbourne was one of the first cities in the world to have a(n embryonic) electricity grid. It's sort of inescapably dry, but still good, necessary knowledge to have.

The gentleman’s guide to vice & virtue by Mackenzi Lee. Well-to-do son of an earl goes on his Grand Tour/1800s gap year. This is charming and queer and well-written, and often deftly funny in that sort of way that looks effortless but takes real skill. It actually reads like quality fanfic (pleasing tropes especially), which I appreciate in spades in a published book. The author does point out racism and sexism, pointedly. I would have also preferred a stab at the colonialism inherent in both the era and the idea of a Tour, but that might have made it a rather different book. As it is, the writing style carries the day. The plot itself wobbles a little on the fact that while alchemy might have been a serious field of study in the 1800s, we still don’t have a cure for (spoiler redacted), so the main impetus falls a little to the side. At 350 of 520 pages, I'm still enjoying myself, though, and I'm really looking forward to the sequel/companion book which focuses on Felicity, who I'm adoring.


Up next:
Not sure. There's a bunch of things that I've either bought (On eating meat, by Matthew Evans), or been gifted (P&P), plus books that are about to come out any second now…(I'm trying to compile a list)

On eating meat, by Matthew Evans – an ethical omnivore’s take on eating meat
The lady’s guide to petticoats and piracy, by Mackenzi Lee
Family of origin – novel by CJ Hauser of above article, which was released two weeks ago.
Growing Up Queer in Australia, edited by Benjamin Law
Quarterly Essay on Safe Schools, Moral Panic 101, by Benjamin Law
Dead Blondes & Bad Mothers: on monsters & the fear of female power, by Sady Doyle, out 13/8/2019
Yes Yes Yes: Australia’s Journey to Marriage Equality by Shirleene Robinson, Alex Greenwich
How powerful we are, by Sally Rugg, out this month. Another marriage equality campaign book, that I’m looking at specifically because there’s apparently a chapter on the impact on queer Australians during the vote, which is not something that I’ve been able to find any sort of data on at all.
The light brigade by Kameron Hurley – still waiting curiously to see if this is going to make it to Australia
Seafire – N C Parker – girl pirates!
maharetr: Comic and movie images of Aisha's eyebrow ring (The Losers) (Default)
( Apr. 4th, 2019 09:53 pm)
Have finished:
My grandmother asked me to tell you she's sorry by Fredrik Backman. Finished, with a few tears on my part, and some low-key odd ableism on the author's part (not naming the 'boy with the syndrome', ever? Really?), and some tiny puzzlements, but still satisfying and I'm glad I read it. Was very similar to Extremely loud and extremely close from some years back, but I liked it much, much better. It felt like it was much less about making a Grand Point, and more about telling a cosy story about a group of people.

Strange waters Samantha Mills. OH GOD. So each year I mean to do at least some reading of the works rounded up by Asking the wrong question's Abigail Nussbaum as Hugo nominations in time to actually add my nomination. This year at least, I got around to reading one or two at all, never mind the long-past deadline *cough*. But HOLY GOD, I hope this short story made it. (ETA: sad it didn't, but so it goes) I love time travel stories So Much, as a preface, and this one both mashed my buttons and is also, I think, devastating in its own right. 6000 or so words and highly recced.

Currently reading:
Spindle's end by Robin McKinley. Despite my frustrations with Beauty, the things I loved about it were enough to sway me into picking up the next available (to me) one. I'd actually read the first page a few times over the last few years, and kept bouncing off it for whatever reason, but apparently cosy domestic magic is 1000% what I'm about right now, because yup here for needing to de-magic your teakettle and asking bread to stay bread, very much. A hundred or so pages in and it strikes me as a deeply leisurely read, and one that I don't wan to rush through for the sake of having read it, so I'm putting it aside for a few months probably because...

Up next:
Clearing the decks because the Hugos are here! The Hugos are here!
Finished reading:
Wonder woman: warbringer by Leigh Bardugo. Okay, I'm now officially a Leigh Bardugo fan. I love this SO fucking much. I'm really glad I persisted with it. It simultaneously didn't read grippingly, at yet I found myself inhaling sharply at tense moments, so something was Really Working. Also the dialogue is sharp and funny, and made me either snicker out loud on the train, or make me hug the book to my chest. It's queer- and fat-positive, and there are So Many Women all over the place, doing things and getting shit done. The ending could have been hokey but Bardugo stuck the landing and it came off as deeply satisfying. Nim is the BEST no-big-deal fat, queer, Indian character, I love her, and also I love Diana So Much. Just like the movie, the 'fish-out-of-water' trope could have been used for cruelty-humour and just like the movie it really, really wasn't, and it's all intrinsically and inalienably feminist and I flail with love.

"I shouldn't have called you names," Theo said. "You're not fat or ugly."
Nim cut him a glance. "I am fat, Theo, and far too hot for your sorry ass."
Just. YES, GOOD. I am so glad this book exists.

Currently reading:
My grandmother asked me to tell you she's sorry by Fredrik Backman. Just started. Ella is seven going on eight. She's not very good at it. (Adults think she's too immature, or too mature, depending on which adult you ask, when). Grandmother is seventy-seven going on seventy-eight. She's not very good at it either. Yeah, okay, I’m smitten.

A hundred pages from the end, and it’s simultaneously charming and hokey, and pat, and weirdly compulsive all at once (that might be my own compulsion to finish things kicking in, but I’ve definitely put books down before, so w/e). I’m pretty sure I can see the denouement coming, and it still feels satisfying. Also it turns out this is a translated novel, and I’m wildly impressed by Henning Koch’s work here. I’ve not read many translations, to be fair (the only other one I can think of reading was attempting Girl with a dragon tattoo and dear god that was wooden), but this reads superbly well.

Up next:
Was going to be Kameron Hurley’s new one, but that’s taking a few weeks to travel through physical space, as things are wont to do. Maybe looking at Charlie Jane Anders’ new one?
Have read:
Any ordinary day: what happens after the worst day of your life? by Leigh Sales. This was a requested Christmas present. I love Sales as an interviewer, and I’d been keenly looking forward to this. The first two thirds of this book I felt were sort of repetitive and lacked depth, maybe. Or at least, I was expecting more depth, although I don’t actually know *how* she could have achieved it. The last third of the book was much more interesting to me – exploring a little bit the people who don’t cope, and touching on why; also talking to those who work in tragedies and work with those who are grieving. It’s been about two months since I finished this, and I can’t say I came away with it with much deep resonating ideas, although I don’t regret reading it, which is also something.

Beauty: a retelling of Beauty and the Beast by Robin McKinnley. I am so torn on this book. I want to give one part of it – the story of her family and the immensely comforting prose (minus a handful of sentences that an editor should have tweaked) five stars. The sequence where Beauty’s family falls on hard times and has to relocate to a small village in the forest, and the descriptions of them cleaning and tending to the house and making it a home, were exactly what I’d been hoping Mandy would be. The atmosphere of the village, and then of the castle, were fantastically top-notch. The actual Beast fairytale… given the previous riches, the beast himself and her “romance” with him were achingly disappointing. It turns out that this book was originally written decades before the Disney movie, so it’s unfair of me to ask a book to interrogate something that didn’t exist yet, but I still wanted a retelling to examine the power imbalance of prisoner/jailer. There was so much that could have been done there – the beast being just as imprisoned as Beauty, and how he felt about ‘having’ to imprison someone in turn as the price of his potential freedom; her developing attraction to him, and how she felt about it; her shift from seeing herself as ‘ugly’ to ‘beauty’; his story of being imprisoned for 200 years… I just… McKinnley/Beauty says she came to trust and love the beast, but I didn’t feel like we saw a damn bit of that developing. I feel like McKinnley didn’t actually want to write the “romance” of the original, so she dodged *everything* to do with that part of the fairy tale, and the story suffered for it so badly. I’m glad I read it for everything else, but she could have made all of it amazing, and I am sad.

Currently reading:
Are you my mother? A comic drama by Alison Bechdel. This has been in my physical to-read pile for literal years. It’s my first actual book of Bechdel’s, and I love the art style, but coming in ‘late’ – not having read Fun Home, for example, the first few chapters of her writing about her mother grated as navel-gazing in a way that it might not have if I’d come to this already in love with her work. But the navel gazing is growing on me, and gets interlaced (beautifully, in the art style) with some legit interesting psychoanalysis, and that addition plus the comic style makes it easy to inhale a chapter before bed, and I’m continuing accordingly.

Wonder woman by Leigh Bardugo. I rather liked the inventiveness and richness of Bardugo's original work Six of crows, so I was excited to see this Wonder Woman tie-in. I’m 30-ish pages in, and it’s slow going, but also slowly hooking me in. It has both the denseness of Six of crows with the slight distancing that often comes with writing characters that aren't your own etc. I’m persisting, moderately interestedly. Also, I had no idea that the Amazons had been mortal women from around the world who had cried out their Goddess’s name while dying in battle, and were therefore granted immortality. That’s the COOLEST CONCEPT, and the movie utterly failed to mention it and I feel robbed. I’m persisting with the book, at least for a while longer.

Up next:
That feels like a very ambitious concept right now...
Tags:
Wednesday reading meme from the last of 2018, cobbled together from mostly-finished drafts that I never got around to posting. I did a rough count, and with some arsey counting [all the hugo short stories as a single novel, for eg], I read a Solid Lot of books by my standards, evening out to a book a fortnight, which is pretty great, and more than I thought I'd done. Yay tracking!

Put aside:
A tenderness of wolves: Picked up because the title had a “is this a classic?” ring to it, and the first page was fantastic, as was the setting and the premise (Woman goes out into Canadian winter wilderness to try and clear her son’s name, or at least find out wtf he did, from memory). But I found myself getting frustrated with it very early on – it’s told in aggressively present tense, even the flashbacks when it ‘should’ have been past tense or past perfect. Artistic licence and all that, but this was a first novel and while it was probably a good first novel, it…should have varied its tenses, dammit. *has judgey feelings*

Bone witch: gorgeous cover, interesting premise, and witches! But then we started getting to “people get a heart jewel necklace that fills with colour to show their True Selves/Destinies” and I’m so Done with rigid predestination McGuffin stories. I don’t even care enough to see if this gets subverted in the end. Returned to library.

Seraphina by Rachel Hart. A book that’s been on my radar for years, and finally picked up. It’s a legit lovely fantasy story of humans and dragons forging an uneasy truce, but it’s also somewhat dense and just enough second-world that I didn't quite have the brain for it so put it aside.

Finished reading:
My own devices by Dessa. Read sometime back, but I forgot to record. I love her rap music, and pre-ordered her memoir. It's more of a collection of loosely connected essays than an autobiography, and once I realised that I liked it a lot more. She's unsurprisingly really good at putting several disparate concepts in proximity, seemingly rambling about them and then pulling them into an impressive gut-punch at the end of many of the essays/chapters. Do rec.

Pirate queen by Morgan Llywelyn. Short telling of the life of (Grace O’Malley) and the conflicts between England and Ireland in the 1500s. Loved it, despite the weird writing, and the lack of any further glossary/bibliography/maps/useful details. I’m desperate for more information about her, but all the biographies I’ve looked up seem to be typo-ridden messes according to reviews, much to my surprise.

Woman world a webcomic(?) in book form. Men die out, right down to the Y-chromosome-sperm in the sperm banks, leaving a world of women. An interconntected series of comics strips with the lightest of narratives strung together with jokes rather than a ‘actual’ story, which wasn’t what I’d expected and threw me for the first half. But I also found myself chuckling out loud quite a lot, so I’m not sure what to make of it. Charming, and A+ for diversity of ages, races, and disabilities.

The thing with Finn by Tom Kelly. Younger YA. Picked up because of the title, the charming art of the cover and the first few pages of excellent first person narrator voice that I wanted to curl up with and learn more about. 20 pages in and I’m delighted by 10-year-old Danny, and wanting to see him process whatever (tragic, I’m assuming) thing happened to his twin brother, Finn. (Finished many months ago, and I can remember that there were some devastatingly good lines about feelings and grief as processed through a child’s eye and/or at a child’s level, but I foolishly didn’t write them down). Do rec.

Mandy by Julie Andrews. A darling, sweet story of a girl who lives in an orphanage, and who comes across a cottage in the woods and fixes up the garden and tends to her little patch of the world. I expected this to hit my emotional buttons much more than it actually ended up doing, and I can't quite put my finger on how and why it missed me. Possibly because she doesn't actually ever live in the cottage? It was well written, it just never hooked me, and I'm legit not sure why.
Tags:
Finished:
The things I didn’t say by Fiona Fornasier. Piper, 17, Australian, has Selective Mutism. I hate the label Selective Mutism - as if I choose not to speak, like a child who refuses to eat broccoli. I've used up every dandelion wish since I was ten wishing for the power to speak whenever I want to. I'm starting to wonder if there are enough dandelions. This was a charming, sweet read. I picked it up because I wanted to learn more about how it felt to have SM, and how to function in the wider world, and it was good for that. The first two-thirds were excellent, the last third fell into blink-worthy melodrama, but I still read it in about two days, and I’m glad I did.

Currently reading:
Magic dirt by Sean Williams. (The best of Sean Williams short stories of the 1990s). Finally unearthing books from my room, and actually giving some of them a go. Read two so far, and they’ve been a nice way to ease into bed of a night. The second story had a particularly good opening set up.
Both of them have had those light moments of "…this was written by a guy" feel about them in the way they mention women characters, but not in a way that makes me want to stop reading, just in a way that I might want to remember for my own writing.

Pirate queen by Morgan Llywelyn. A kid’s historical short novel about the Irish pirate queen Granuaile vs the queen of England, Elizabeth I. The writing is present tense and wooden and frankly strange, but Ganuaile is So Great. SO GREAT. Given it’s a Children Will Learn novel I really want a Gaelic pronunciation guide, and possibly a sailing glossary while they’re at it. I’m persisting with it, because short and also she is SO GREAT.

Up next:
Mandy by Julie Andrews is in fact allegedly in the post!
Tags:
Put aside:
A tenderness of wolves by Stef Penney: Picked up because the title had a "is this a classic?" ring to it, and the first page was fantastic, as was the setting and the premise (Woman goes out into Canadian winter wilderness to try and clear her son's name, or least find out wtf he did, from memory). But I found myself getting frustrated with it very early on - it's told in aggressively present tense, even the flashbacks when it 'should' have been past tense or past perfect. Artistic licence and all that, but this was a first novel and it was probably a good first novel, it…should have varied its tenses, dammit. *has judgey feelings, plus I really like tense changes*

Bone witch Rin Chupeco: gorgeous cover, interesting premise, and witches! But then we started getting to "people get a heart jewel necklace that fill with colour to show their True Selves/Destinies" and I'm so Done with rigid pre-destination stories. Returned to library.

Finished
a record of a spaceborn few by Becky Chambers. I liked it - all of the many characters had time to breathe and got satisfying arcs - but I cannot overstate how little plot there is. It is not necessarily a bad thing: Chambers clearly wanted to do a character novel, and that's fine, but there was very little narrative drive as a result. This is my second favourite of the three novels (the second being my most favourite) but I'm still very keen to see what she comes up with next.

My Candlelight novel by Joann Horniman. This is the sequel/companion novel to the novel of my heart (Secret Scribbled Notebooks). I was delighted to find it in a second-hand bookshop and to own a copy of both. I love it still even if I'd rewritten some parts of it in my memory in the intervening years. Queer (bisexual) YA.

Woman world by Aminder Dhwaliwal. A webcomic(?) in book form. Men die out, right down to the Y-chromosome-sperm in the sperm banks, leaving a world of women. An interconntected series of comics strips with the lightest of narratives strung together with jokes rather than a 'actual' story, which wasn't what I'd expected and threw me for the first half. But I also found myself chuckling out loud quite a lot, so I'm not sure what to make of it. Charming, and A+ for diversity of ages, races, and disabilities.

The thing with Finn by Tom Kelly. Younger YA. Picked up because of the title, the charming art of the cover and the first few pages of excellent first person narrator voice that I wanted to curl up with and learn more about. A 10-year-old boy, Danny, and whatever (tragic) thing happened to his twin brother, Finn.
(Having now finished) This was a wonderful, perfectly-distilled-10-year-old voice that makes some really incisive points about grief and feelings, and I was very impressed. I'm not sure what the actual significance of the last page or so was, but that doesn't stop me from reccing this highly.


Currently reading:

Seraphina by Rachel Hart. A book that's been on my radar for years, and finally picked up. It's a legit lovely fantasy story of humans and dragons forging an uneasy truce, but it's also somewhat dense and just enough second-world that I don't quite have the brain for atm, so pausing it for a few days to read The thing with Finn. Going to open it up and try again.

Up next:
I'm really hoping that Mandy by Julie Andrews actually exists in Dymocks' warehouse somewhere.
Tags:
Finished reading:
Terra Nullius by Claire G Coleman. The premise of this is absolutely fantastic. It's also her first novel, which shows up in jarring ways: strange sentences, and somewhat underdeveloped characters. It's such a good premise, though – that genuinely, to my shame, helped reframe my thinking on its topic – that I'm willing to give her a pass, and look interestedly to whatever her next project turns out to be.

Jessica Jones: Alias vol. 1. The art style is a little static – possibly intentionally, but I prefer more movement in my frames... I say, as if I have the knowledge to pass judgment on this stuff. I really don't. But the writing and the pacing is otherwise absolutely fantastic. I love Jessica and all her fuckups, and her wry, bitter voice, the Matt Murdoch cameos, and Carol Danvers as her long-suffering friend and support. I am so here for it, and so far, would totally read the other three volumes even with the Kilgrave storyline. (Content note for borderline sex-as-self-harm in the first few pages of this volume, not graphic, though.)

Up next: (as if in, starting sometime this evening probably)
(Hugh Howey's) Wool, which turns out to be a standalone graphic novel of one of his first books – first self-published, then picked up for a substantial book contract. Interested, with slight trepidation now.

Up later:
The house of shattered wings by Aliette de Bodard. Interested for this one.

Record of a spaceborn few by Becky Chambers. Her first book was Good with minor flaws. HE second was tight, and excellent. I’m really, really excited to see what she’s got for her third.
Tags:
I fell off the wagon for a while there. In retrospect I burned out hard on reading Hugo works.

Finished reading
Six of crows by Leigh Bardougo. This was like a rich, meaty stew. Seriously, for some reason all the metaphors I can think of are related to food. A heist novel set in a fantasy-magicked Victorian London. This has fantastically dense, chewy (see?) worldbuilding, which made for slower but more rewarding reading. I liked many of these characters in their flawed way, although six was possibly slightly too many to keep in the air (or maybe just in my head) at once. Very well-realised...basically everything, although I tend to drift once we get into the nitty-gritty of the actual heists and trust the author will flag when things are/aren't working properly. Legit interested in reading the sequel – this book did a fair job of wrapping up the current plot while leaving enough tempting hooks for next book. I'd heard whispers about queer rep, which was why I picked it up to be honest, and it's there in secondary characters, and both subtle and correspondingly utterly unremarked, and I liked it for that.

Currently reading
Terra Nullius by Claire G. Coleman. Set in an Australia of Settlers vs Natives, of early Protectionist days. I really want to like this, but the writing style is taking some getting used to – the grammar is waving back and forth between being 'non-standard' to being flat out 'that sentence has wandered away and gotten lost'. But the more I read the more I adjusted and settled into it, I'm keen to keep reading, and glad I stuck with it.

Up next
Jessica Jones vol 1
Wool Vol. 1
Both impulse grabs from the local library.

THEN The house of shattered wings by Aliette de Bodard. I've heard good things about this and am v interested.
Tags:
maharetr: Comic and movie images of Aisha's eyebrow ring (The Losers) (Default)
( Jun. 24th, 2018 08:59 pm)
SUPER late, but I was also out Wednesday, Thursday, Friday nights, so it goes.

Finished reading/put aside:
Crash Override: how Gamergate (nearly) destroyed my life, and how we came win the fight against online hate by Zoe Quinn. Now finished, and everything from my last review stands x2. Highest possible rec.

Provenance by Ann Leckie: I got the book from my local library to give myself longer than the excerpt to see if I settled into it, and only after reading whatever-chunk longer and waiting for the character to get over her birthright/fighting for inheritence thing did I think to read the blurb (I know, I know. Just, starting my reading from a PDF download does that sometimes, apparently), and realised that the whole book is about that and I am so not interested in that narrative. There’s very good odds the narrative is about her actually learning to disregard her ‘birthright’ and forging out on her own, but it feels like it’s going to take way too long for it to get there.

Iain M. Banks by Paul Cincaid. (Read the first two-ish chapters) This is clearly deeply researched, and I imagine an abosolutely fascinating read if you’ve read Banks’ works. I’ve only read a handful, and they were long enough ago that I don’t clearly remember them. I want to be the sort of person who has done the background reading to justify purchasing the rest of this, but alas I’m not. Strong rec, for people who have, though. It looks like a good book.

The art of starving by Sam J Miller. Oh boy. I inhaled the first …fifty pages? And mega, huge trigger warnings for anyone who’s ever had an eating disorder of any kind, pretty much. I’ve not had one, and I also read a fair number of anorexia/ED angsty books as a teen and… thinking back, all of those books were clear enough in their ‘while the character is deep inside their eating disorder, the author is pointing out this is Bad Idea’. There was a level of distance, even while you were inside a sufferer’s head. This is…the author is drawing on his experiences of his own past eating disorder, and it’s SO assured it’s genuinely headfucky, even to someone who’s never actually been there. I’d definitely read more of this author, but I don’t think I can do it myself.

Currently reading
No time to spare by Ursula Le Guin. A compilation of the last decade or so of her blog posts. As always (and now eternally I guess) her turn of phrase is so seemly perfect and effortless. I abruptly want to find like, there’s an archive full of famous authors’ hand edits of their drafts, and I would sell a…something, to be given access to her versions of that. Reading it is still as immensely comforting, laced with bittersweet.

Up next:
I might dip into Sleeping with Monsters: Readings and Reactions in Science Fiction and Fantasy, by Liz Bourke, or back into fiction with In Other Lands, by Sarah Rees Brennan
Tags:
Finished reading:
All systems red by Martha Wells. I genuinely expected to like this, and I’m still not sure why it didn’t hook me. I’m there for So Many of those tropes: ‘what happened to the earlier crew?’; people being kind to those that most people aren’t kind to; people who aren’t considered people. Also I realise belatedly that this novella is the one I've seen many raving about. And yet I was never hooked – I read the first third? Half? And then jumped forward to read the last chapter, absently, and while I’m glad for the main character, I wasn’t interested in seeing them get there. It wasn’t bad by any stretch, it just never pinged me. *emoji shrug*

Down among the sticks and bones by Seanan McGuire. I was immensely frustrated by the first published in this series, to the point where I nearly didn’t read this prequel. But oh my god, I was utterly transfixed by this. I felt like there was a glorious depth now that she only needed to focus on two characters, and I loved the world and how creepy-as-ordinary it was. This is actually in all seriousness doing battle with And then there was (n-one) for first place on the novella ballot. I did not expect that at all.

Put aside (much less harsh than did not finish)
River of Teeth by Sarah Gailey (Tor.com Publishing): the writing is skilled, the premise (America starts farming hippoes in the south) is inspired, there’s an agender (they/them) character who is also desired by the main protagonist \o/. I really liked this … except for the act of vicious mutilation-then-murder by the main protagonist really close to the start. And okay, probably he’s being positioned as an anti-hero, but when the main (apparent) antagonist is dealing out less violence with more 'cause' than the antagonist…nope. I’m really bummed. : (

The Black Tides of Heaven by JY Yang (Tor.com Publishing): I also really wanted to like this one. A culture where gender is not decided until the early teens means we have two they/them pronouned twin main characters, which kudos, dude. But the writing was not quite tight enough, or the emerging plot quite interesting enough to hold me for the entire novella.

Luminescent threads A series of people's love and appreciation letters to Octavia E Butler ten years after her death and just after 45 got elected. It's unsettling somehow that just enough time has passed that we now have books referencing the 45th presidency. It makes for an amazing moment-in-time book, triply so because this moment is in the process of unfolding right now. The letters are gutting and heartfelt, and I'm really glad this book exists, but having only read one of Butler's books, I'm not feeling the urge to read the entire thing.

Currently reading
Crash Override: how Gamergate (nearly) destroyed my life, and how we came win the fight against online hate by Zoe Quinn. Her publishers were kind enough to give an excerpt of the entire first half of the book in the voters pack, and I went and spent $20 on the ebook unhesitatingly to reward that and also give Quinn money. The first half is a harrowing read of what her Ex and co put her through. The second half is what she’s doing after, and examining the haters (who are us, who are all of us in the ‘right’ conditions), and spent the first half horrified and what I’ve read of the second shouting “YES, THAT. Jesus.” A lot. She provides really good advice on digital protection, and what to do if you get in someone’s crosshairs, and how to help someone when you’re a friend or bystander. I wish she’d provided references, but this is still really, really good and really important. Strong rec.

Up next: Maybe Iain Banks, maybe Ursula Le Guin.
Tags:
Finished reading:
A skinful of shadows by Frances Hardinge. This was a really satisfyingly crafted and resolved story. It felt like a very moral and human tale, and I appreciated it keenly for that. Also the ending was immensely satisfying to me. Now I’m in the voting conundrum of: “I was more emotionally engaged with La belle sauvage, but Shadows was an infinitely better book”. *angsts at the YA ballot*

The collapsing empire by John Scalzi. I’m loving this. Scalzi’s writing is assured and fucking funny – it’s making me laugh out loud several times a chapter. And then something awful happens, and it’s making me catch my breath and bite my lip to ward off the emotional wallop. I feel like it could be… deeper? I’m fumbling for words. Perhaps I’m used to fat fantasy rather than space opera, but it’s only 300 pages long, and while it’s getting its point across well, I keep expecting something more complicated, or more depth from somewhere. But it’s still a very good read.

[Having now finished] I figured out what was bugging me: this is 3/4 of a novel. It’s a really good three quarters, I loved it, but it’s missing a chunk of worldbuilding and depth that was supposed to make me care about the point of the novel. (That sounds more dire than it actually is). But when there were [character deaths] I felt them viscerally, one so intensely that I read it that first time and then turned the page so I didn’t re-read and cry in public. But that …not even a twist, a pivot point – that didn’t feel earned, because the depth of this world felt as deep as “as much as was needed to write these particular set of characters” rather than ‘fleshing out a living, breathing world’ and that’s a damn shame.

Currently reading:
All systems red by Martha Wells. I’m a couple of pages in, and I cautiously think I’m going to like it.

Up next:
ALLLL the rest of the novellas (well, the four I haven’t read yet).
Tags:
.

Profile

maharetr: Comic and movie images of Aisha's eyebrow ring (The Losers) (Default)
maharetr

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags